Advertisement
Advertisement

Smith Brothers, WW 1

Updated Mar 10, 2025
Loading...one moment please loading spinner
Smith Brothers, WW 1
This undated photo provided by the Smith family shows four of the five Smith brothers, who were killed during World War I, pose for a photo in Barnard Castle, England. Clockwise from bottom left, John W Stout, Alfred, George Henry and Frederick.

Queen Mary, wife of King George V, heard about the sacrifice of the brothers and intervened to send the sixth, Willie, home.

Robert 22, died first, in September 1916. George Henry, 26, died less than two months later.

Frederick, 21, died in July 1917, while the eldest, 37-year-old John William Stout — who had their mother’s maiden name because she was not yet married when he was born — died in October 1917. The fifth son, Alfred, died in July 1918.

The mother’s grief was apparently more than the vicar’s wife could bear. She wrote to Queen Mary about the deaths of Margaret’s five sons and how she had a sixth son still at war.

Although he suffered from the effects of being gassed, once home, Willie worked as a chimney sweep and a stone mason.

"Saving Private Smith"
Date & Place: in Barnard Castle, County Durham County, England DL12, United Kingdom
Comments
Leave a comment
The simple act of leaving a comment shows you care.
Four of six English sons who went to the "war to end all wars" over 100 years ago and never returned.
That's why they made the rule: No more than one son can be in a war--I think that's right.
Photo of AncientFaces AncientFaces
via Facebook
03/27/2019
And yet, in WW2, both my father and uncle fought - the only two boys in the family.
Photo of Suzanne Berglund-Edwards Suzanne Berglund-Edwards
via Facebook
03/27/2019
Susan Baum Schloss did they both make it home?
Photo of AncientFaces AncientFaces
via Facebook
03/27/2019
Suzanne Berglund-Edwards Yes they did! Our family has had men in every war in the U.S. since the French-Indian War, before we were the U.S. I guess that's why we're still here! :)
Photo of Joan Pasquarelli Joan Pasquarelli
via Facebook
03/27/2019
They can be sent to war but not sent to the same place at the same time . The Sullivan Brothers died because they wanted to stay together and all went down with the ship after that no more together
Photo of AncientFaces AncientFaces
via Facebook
03/27/2019
Joan Pasquarelli I'm not educated on that, but it may be true. My Dad fought in the Pacific, my uncle in the Atlantic.
Photo of Joan Pasquarelli Joan Pasquarelli
via Facebook
03/27/2019
AncientFaces My Dad was a lifer in the Navy . There is an old movie on the Sullivan’s life is a heart breaker but good .
Photo of Fran Portnoy Fran Portnoy
via Facebook
03/27/2019
Yes, AncientFaces, Joan Pasquarelli is correct. The new ruling forbade brothers from serving together for the reason Joan gave.
Photo of Ellen Spooner-Sherin Ellen Spooner-Sherin
via Facebook
03/27/2019
Susan Baum Schloss The Sullivan Bros - I think 7 ---WW2
Photo of Ellen Spooner-Sherin Ellen Spooner-Sherin
via Facebook
03/27/2019
5 brothers 😪
Remember the Sullivan brothers ? I believe there were five and all died in World War ll. They were in the US Navy. So very sad......
Photo of Donna Richwalski Winski Donna Richwalski Winski
via Facebook
03/27/2019
Beverly Brucker yes, you are correct. I watched the movie. The fighting Sullivan’s when I was young and never forgot the story.
Photo of Walter Argent Walter Argent
via Facebook
03/28/2019
Donna Richwalski Winski They all served together on the USS Juneau which was sunk. As a result of this, they separated family.
Photo of Melanie Viselli Melanie Viselli
via Facebook
03/27/2019
My great-grandfather (Alfred Hollowell) and 3 of his brothers served in WWI from here in the US...3 (including Alfred) were in the same regiment. There were 13 kids in that family altogether. Most of them lived to be well into their 80s or 90s. The one brother out of the four died in his mid 50s. From everything my grandmother had been able to tell me, he had been caught in some sort of gas attack during the war and his health was never the same after that.
Photo of Pat Hunter-Cunningham Pat Hunter-Cunningham
via Facebook
03/29/2019
Same thing happened to my grandfather. I think he died in his early to mid 30's. My dad was only 6 or 7 years old.
Photo of Becky Kelly Becky Kelly
via Facebook
03/27/2019
Love these old pictures.
Photo of Shirley Beresford Shirley Beresford
via Facebook
03/27/2019
WW1, in my husband's family, 4 sisters were nurses, and 1 son in Army
Photo of Linda Davis Watson Linda Davis Watson
via Facebook
03/28/2019
My paternal grandparents had four sons in WWII. Fortunately they all came home.
Photo of Scilla Webb Robison Scilla Webb Robison
via Facebook
03/28/2019
In UK during WW1 they used to send all recruits from the same village into the same regiment so that they could be together. After villages lost all of their young men, recruiting in that manner stopped. Too late for many villages all over UK though :(
My Grandpa served in WW1 in the Royal Flying Corp. My Dad and his 2 brothers in WW2. Also 4 Canadian cousins, two of which lost their lives. One on D-day and the other later on in Belgium.
Thank them so very much for keeping us free. You are America's allies and we love you for it. My dad was in WWII, South Pacific, Navy.
Photo of Scilla Webb Robison Scilla Webb Robison
via Facebook
03/28/2019
Cindy Roll They have all passed now but I accept your thanks on their behalf. Such brave generations.
Photo of Mila Laura Mila Laura
via Facebook
03/28/2019
Siento mucha compasión por quienes han tenido que vivir el karma de la guerra. Pero la guerra es así, van a matar y a ser matados, van en nombre de su patria o de lo que quieran llamar, pero van a matar y a ser matados. Dios nos libre a todos de semejante karma.
Photo of Melanie Viselli Melanie Viselli
via Facebook
03/29/2019
I have a newspaper clipping some friggin where with my great-grandfather and the 2 brothers that shared a regiment posing together....there was some sort of anniversary for some of the guys from WWI out of that regiment, I don't know if it was like a 50th anniversary thing or what. All 3 brothers were up in age at that point...I will have to find it sometime and share it here. I love that clipping.
Photo of George Brown George Brown
via Facebook
04/01/2019
Donna Richwalski Winski Shortly after, a newly commissioned Warship was Christened The USS Sullivan in Their Honor..
Share this photo:
Advertisement

Topic related photos

England
England
England has such a rich history that has spread across various countries and across the globe: This collection of historical photos highlights the English people, and shows the locations from which many of our families came.
England, one part of the United Kingdom, was formed as a unified kingdom in about the 900s CE. The kingdom went on to become a dominant European power after the Norman Conquest in 1066. The English ...
552 photos
World War I
World War I
These vintage photos of World War I's battlefields offer a glimpse into the lives of soldiers and civilians.
World War I (1914-1918) was a global conflict between the Central Powers (led by Germany, Austria-Hungary, and the Ottoman Empire) and the Allied Powers (led by France, Great Britain, and Russia) tha...
Army
Army
These photos showcase the bravery and sacrifice of the men and women who have served in the army.
The army has played a pivotal role throughout history, defending nations, promoting peace, and supporting humanitarian efforts. The people and battles serve as a vivid reminder of our loved ones' crit...
Smith
Last name
890k+ people1.68k+ photos
Advertisement

Followers

Gaye Thomas
About me:I haven't shared any details about myself.
Lena Tate-Ervin
About me:I haven't shared any details about myself.
Melissa DeRisi Spilka
About me:I haven't shared any details about myself.
Jeanette Hinz
About me:I haven't shared any details about myself.
Errol Wong
About me:I haven't shared any details about myself.

Show more

Advertisement
Back to Top