If she is Jewish her life span could be shortened in that era. If she is a child of Nazis or Nazi sympathizers she will grow up surrounded by Predjudice and if her family are merely trying to survive the terrible times she will grow up apprehensively. At the time the picture was taken she was an innocent tyke.
True, but aren't we suppose to learn from the past. She is a sweet little girl living among the evil of Nazi rule. It doesn't matter what category or group "they" would have put her in. WE are suppose to be better than that. History .... Like it or hate it. It's true. Great photo of History.
It matters to the interpretation of the photo. Did she die in the camps? Or in the bombings? Were the people who bought her the dolly vehement Nazis, or just German people who were caught up in the movement? Did they resist? Where did they end up? It doesn't matter in the sense that she's just a child but the context changes the way you interpret the photo. It's not a positive or a negative necessarily.
I know she is just a child, an innocent. My query was more to the environment she grew up in (if indeed she got to grow up at all) and that relates to how poignant the photo is for me. She may be innocent but her elders may not have been if you see my point.If they were Nazis or sympathizers she would grow up with a different ( ie barbaric) view of the world and the atrocities her "people" were inflicting on others. Obviously she was alive in Nazi Germany and that HAD to have influenced her childhood .
@Annette Masloh, Can't Catherine just ask a question that wonders what future awaited her? It's a valid point to wonder. It's normal. Of course the little girl is innocent. That goes without saying. But, really, would you like people to be so worried about being misinterpreted that they are afraid to voice a logical and natural question that the photo is practically asking us to consider? If we don't think about the photo, we are not making use of this historical record.
Kelly, i think you should read up on the Anabaptist resistance, and Dietrich Bonhoffer , and then try to understand the difference between nationality and political power.Jewish children who survived and avoided concentration camps did so because of Germans who did not agree with the power politic and risked everything because of it.
Yes you can't paint all Germans with a broad brush of Nazism for sure. But THAT always raises more questions with me!! I was in Germany in 2010 and all around me were normal people going about their normal daily lives and all I could think of when I saw someone in their 70's was "what were you doing during the war?" Were they SS officers back then, actively killing Jewish people? Were they part of the administration stamping documents that sent people to concentration camps? Were they young Hitler Youth? Were they caught up in a movement beyond their control? And then what? Did they just go back to their normal lives? It's all so fascinating to me. (and horrifying) I know I am not explaining myself adequately. But I wonder these things.
This is very similar to a picture I have of my mother, who was about that age as well in 1940. I love the innocence and sweetness of this picture. It makes me wonder what her future held.
De chaque côté du Rhin, des enfants qui ne comprenaient pas, et qui ont conservé le traumatisme d'une guerre qui les marqueront pour le restant de leur vie. Ils furent nos parents pour les plus jeunes d'entre nous, nos aînés pour les moins jeunes...
Terrible and disturbing picture. Could've been killed by bombings from the allied nations as well. She was just a kid, had nothing to do with ideology.
Well whatever Isreal is doing to the innocent Palestinian children is 10x worst then what 'happened' to them. The past is the past, so let's learn from it and never repeat the same mistakes.
What the American doing with the Native Indian , the send them to Disneyland for fun? HELL NO ,I think a lot be in Camps , what do the American in Hiroschima? Australien with the Aborigines ??? So many Contrys still be mad , so u be the biggest Rassict Catherine Hudson Green u need really bad help !
And Eileen Drew i live my whole Life in Germany , and no one called me in Nazi or Kraut , only Dumb PP Judge Pp like u , in this way ...so please get a Life ...i have Friends in the whole World but not one be a Dumb Rassict ....
The little doll looks so sad. Wonder who made it. Such a sweet innocent little girl! Grateful she wasn't old enough to understand the horrors all around her! :(
Looking at this reminds me of the wonderful book "The Book Thief" ... the story was from this time period and left me feeling truly disturbed ... The streets look barren as described in the book. What a time in history!!!!
Just looking at the photo creates such an eerie feeling of ghosts walking around. I am so grateful that this little girl was given a long life. I seriously hope she had a good life though. How do we explain the words what we feel when we see such disturbing photos like this. Angry, sad, helpless and what not. Just saying... thank you for sharing because we all have to be reminded of this and pray that history doesnt repeat it self... yeah I know.
These historical photos have generated quite the buzz!
This collection of historical photos has got people talking. These photos - either because of the subject and/or the story - have generated a lot of comments among the community. What do you have to s...
The most fun ever - toys! Toys have changed a lot over the years, but they serve the same purpose - bringing joy to our lives.
What's childhood without play? And what's play without toys? Toys are an important part of a child's development and our toys have changed with the times. Here are some of the toys and dolls of the p...
Portrait photographs and paintings of our loved ones and ancestors.
Before photos we had paintings of family members - most usually these were reserved for the well off. The era of modern photography began with the daguerreotype, in 1839. Since the advent of photogr...