Who killed Central New York woman in 1973 remains a mystery
The following was published on May 5, 2021 on syracuse.com, written by James McClendon:
Oneida Castle, N.Y. — It’s been nearly 50 years, and state police are still searching for answers in the mysterious 1973 death of an Oneida County woman. The mystery started on July 26, 1973 when Martha Louise Allen’s grandfather reported her missing after she left their 9th Street home in Oneida Castle, according to a news release issued by New York State police this week.
More than three weeks later on Aug. 17, Allen’s partially decomposed body was found by a boater in Black Creek near the Verona Beach State Park, police said. Allen — who was 21 years old — was last seen by her grandfather at about 8:30 a.m. on July 25, before he left the home for a trip to the Syracuse area for the day, troopers said. She was wearing red, white and blue striped shorts, a lavender-colored tank top and thick-rimmed glasses, according to the release. She had brown hair and brown eyes, troopers said.
The 5-foot-3, 120-pound woman was later seen by neighbors at about 7:10 p.m. on July 25, 1973 walking through Village Park in Oneida Castle, according to The Post-Standard archives. Investigators later had reason to believe an Oneida County business owner, Donald Sigsbee, may have been involved in Allen’s death, after an index card with her name was discovered at the man’s cabinet-making business two years later, according to the archives. The card was discovered during an investigation into the murder of 19-year-old SUNY Morrisville student Regina Reynolds in 1975, according to the archives. In 2004, Sigsbee was found guilty of second-degree murder for the stabbing death of Reynolds, according to the archives. State police investigators found that Allen and Sigsbee knew each other, according to the archives. Sigsbee had made Allen — who was interested in Egyptian artifacts — an Egyptian-style sword, according to the archives.
Sigsbee also was a suspect in the deaths of three other young girls — Teri Fuller, 19, of Chittenango, Paula Burke, 12, of Chittenango, and SUNY Cobleskill student Kathy Kolodziej, 17, of Ronkonkoma, Long Island — in Central New York between 1974 and 1976, according to archives. Those cases are also still unsolved, according to archives.
Sigsbee died in 2009 while serving a 25-year-to-life sentence at the Mohawk Correctional Facility in Rome, according to New York State prison records. He was 74 years old when he died.
Troopers ask anyone with information about these deaths to call state police at 315-366-6000.