Murderer Found Guilty and Sentenced to Life in Prison
Tuffy Pleasant was arrested on suspicion of the two murders and now the mysteries behind the deaths of Blankenbaker and Moore were explained. In taped statements, Pleasant described how he had idolized his coach, Gabby Moore, the man who had promised that one day he, too, could be a coach at Davis High School Pleasant had seen the disintegration of his idol, his obsessive misery over Dee Ann, and had tried to talk him out of it. "It was Dee Ann this... Dee Ann that." Pleasant said.
"We were so close that what he felt, I felt. If he shed a tear, I shed a tear. This man, he's just tore up. He's not himself, just bleeding inside. He said, if you have a problem, you eliminate it. And Morris was his number one problem. Out of his admiration for his coach, out of his sympathy for the man's distress, Pleasant made a bloody pact. He would "eliminate" Moore's problem for him. Moore called him from the hospital on Nov. 21st and said, "Tonight's the night, while I'm in here." Pleasant borrowed the gun and went out to kill Blankenbaker.
The death of Moore, Pleasant said, was a bizarre extension of the pact. Moore was determined to divert Dee Ann's suspicion that he had played a role in the death of Blankenbaker. He became convinced that he had to suffer a wound from the same weapon so that she would believe someone else was bent on killing both her husbands. He wanted Pleasant to use the 22 pistol to shoot him, "just to wound him," in the shoulder. Then Moore planned to crawl across the street to Dee Ann's sister's house, winning both sympathy and freedom from suspicion. Pleasant said he had refused until Moore started to dial the police, threatening to report that it was Pleasant who had killed Blankenbaker. Trapped, Pleasant had agreed to the scenario. But, he said, Moore had drunk so much whisky to help him endure the pain of the wound that as the shot was fired at him he stumbled and the bullet penetrated lower than planned, and Gabby Moore had died, the victim of his own weird plan.
On August 29, a jury found Pleasant guilty of murder in the death of Blankenbaker and of manslaughter in the shooting of Moore, his beloved coach. He was sentenced to life for the murder and to 20 years for the manslaughter.
Publilhsed Sunday November 21, 1976 in the Daily News (New York, New York)